Last fall, I wrote about the decisions my long-distance boyfriend and I were making about where we might live once we were married. We got engaged shortly after and decided, once and for all, that Josh would leave Canada to join me in Madison and go back to grad school after our September wedding.

Then we learned, along with the rest of the world, that there is no “once and for all” during a pandemic.

We had a few months of blissful planning. Deposits were paid to a caterer and venue (Ladies Lit Club, how cool is that?). I picked out a dress. We signed a lease for a gorgeous little apartment in Madison within biking distance from my work. We emailed our wedding vendors about tiny details that seemed of utmost importance, like “what’s the difference between your dance floor lighting options?”

Even until a month ago, we held out hope for the wedding and future we envisioned. Thrilled to be staying in my city, I daydreamed about future Madison life: bringing Josh into my friend group and teaching him our favorite board games. Keeping “roommate night” traditions and letting my dog play in Susan’s new backyard. Growing houseplants with Monica’s help as she brings over cuttings of her overgrown jade tree. Joining the rest of Madison at the famed summer farmer’s market.

Applying for Josh’s visa seemed like an afterthought. We’d get married, and then he could live here. No big deal.

Then, of course, the pandemic hit. The borders closed; Trump tweeted about not letting anyone into the country. We had a few conversations with immigration attorneys and faced a hard truth. Misunderstood timelines on our part and halted immigration processes on the United States’ part meant that Josh’s fiancé visa couldn’t possibly be granted in time for our wedding. Even if we somehow worked around that, he couldn’t work or attend school here.

Our plans screeched to a halt.  

What were the alternatives? We could delay our wedding a year, so that the visa could be settled and Josh could start school in the fall of 2021. But I pictured myself living alone in the Madison apartment, and even that front-load washer and those hip light fixtures couldn’t make up for the struggle of another year of long-distance engagement. 

As we discussed our options, our potential fall wedding shrank before our eyes. Even if stay-at-home orders have loosened by then, there still won’t be a COVID-19 vaccine. Could we even have a gathering of fifty people? Twenty? Everything we envisioned was crumbling. 

This pandemic has been a time for everyone to reevaluate their priorities. Josh and I talked about ours over long evening phone calls. What do we really value: throwing a big wedding? Living in Madison? Or starting our life together as soon as we can, no matter what dreams we have to let go of for now?

Josh was surprised when I brought up moving to Canada. But it is a viable way forward. Immigration is a little easier, and I could live there while our application is being processed. I could do remote IT work while waiting for a work permit, and Josh could continue getting counseling experience. If we stay one year, we could come back to Madison next fall. If we stay three years, Josh might not need to go back to grad school. 

When we terminated our Madison lease, I sobbed. I’d known when Josh and I started dating that I might have to leave. But staying was within our grasp, and it feels nice to know what your future is going to look like. 

“Now listen,” James 4:13-15 says. “You who say, ‘Today or tomorrow we will go to this or that city, spend a year there, carry on business and make money.’ Why, you do not even know what will happen tomorrow. What is your life? You are a mist that appears for a little while and then vanishes. Instead, you ought to say, ‘If it is the Lord’s will, we will live and do this or that.’”

Is it the Lord’s will that we live in Toronto? Was Madison a divinely closed door, or just a plan we screwed up? If we had just started our application earlier, gotten Josh accepted to a program that permits student visas, if…if…. But we didn’t. And even if we did, there’s a worldwide pandemic.

If it is the Lord’s will, we will have some kind of wedding in September. Now I try to dream about a new life in Toronto. Skyscrapers and feeling small in a big city. Getting to know new coffee shops and unfamiliar cuisine. Learning more Korean to talk with his parents. Watching the CN tower in the distance and reminiscing about our first date there.

Our life plans feel so small amidst the global upheaval of COVID-19. I learn something new every day about what my future may or may not hold. But if Josh and I can get married and pursue the Lord’s will together, that is the plan that matters most.


  1. Avatar

    Laura, you did such a nice job with this. I’m so sorry this has happened to you and Josh (and so many others–I own a wedding venue now).

  2. Avatar

    Thanks for sharing your life with us. The last few months have been and the next few months (years?) will be a “different” time for all of us; a “very difficult” time for many, if not most of us. I do feel for you and Josh. We do not know what the future holds but we do know Who holds the future. I was very blessed by your last sentence, “But if Josh and I can get married and pursue the Lord’s will together, that is the plan that matters most.” God bless you and keep you.

  3. Avatar

    Laura, this is a beautiful, vulnerable, and sad post. Yet, since we know and walk with Jesus, we can be sure He’ll use all of these hard situations for your good and to draw you and Josh closer to Him. Doesn’t make the current issues any less hard. But it does inject much hope for your future. Who knows what will come from your lives together in Canada that would not otherwise have happened. It’s great to see the last line of your post. It’s clear you are already resting in these truths.

  4. Avatar

    I too was enriched by your post. Kept thinking of you every time I heard of the closed border, even with Canada. I had an invite to two weddings of family members, both postponed. But that pain pales next to yours. I am leaving the two small churches I have been pastoring the last 12 to 30 months, respectively. staying at HPC, and looking for work I can do remotely from Madison, using my passion for writing and mission. Hope to see you before you leave for Canada.

  5. Kyric Koning

    All we can do is keep moving forward, trusting in the Lord. It is not easy. Especially for those of us planners. “Things weren’t supposed to go this way!” keeps our view too centered on ourselves. There’s more at stake than that.

    But still, I sympathize and empathize. Trusting isn’t always fun.

  6. Avatar

    Laura, great to catch up with you a bit! I found you on this site through following up an essay by Josh Parks and then clicking on to see if I knew any of the other ex-Calvin students on the site. Lovely essay. Canada seems like a good place to be now.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar posts

post calvin direct

Get new posts from Laura Sheppard Song delivered straight to your inbox.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!