Our theme for the month of June is “sex and the church.” To read posts from our first pass at this theme, check out our June 2018 archives.

As someone who is newly part of the Christian Reformed Church and was raised Christian but isn’t, like, theological about it, I know enough about sex rules to get by. When the church gives guidelines on sexuality immorality, whether that be sex outside of marriage or sex between two people of the same sex, celibacy is the silver bullet. You can be gay, but keep it PG-13. You can date people and have fun, but no matter how old you are you can’t have sex until you’re married. When in doubt, celibate it out.

I am not particularly bothered by celibacy. Sure, I enjoyed a good sex scene in a novel. I’ve had physically intimate moments, the most intense one being someone tenderly touching my belly. It lead to an epiphany of sorts (wow, people can connect physically) but not to the epiphany I was looking for (i.e. it was not “Oh I do want to have sex”). So when the church repeatedly reminded me that I couldn’t have sex in my current state of affairs, I basically shrugged and went, “Okay, whatever.”

After exploring and probing my asexuality more, though, I’m finding it harder and harder to swallow the celibacy route. 

The church has framed celibacy as a punishment: you’re not doing sex in the right context, you unmarried harlot, so you aren’t allowed to have it at all. Since you are not heterosexual, you have to atone for it by giving up physical intimacy with a partner (and still be grateful that you are accepted here in church at all). Sex is so good, the church says—it was created by God to bring humans closer together, but you don’t get to experience it unless you check all the boxes. Don’t you want it so so bad? Aren’t you willing to do the right things so you get to have it? Isn’t not having sex awful?

Earlier this year, I took part in a Colossian Way small group focused on human sexuality, and we discussed celibacy a lot. In one of the lessons, a gay man told his story about growing up in the church, wrestling with his sexuality, and eventually deciding to be celibate and foster deep connections in his church. As someone who doesn’t plan on having sex and enjoys having deep connections within her church, I felt decidedly uncomfortable. Sure, he found an option he was happy with, but how much was his hand forced by the church? Would he have still chosen celibacy if the church had gone further in their LGBTQ+ inclusion?

Don’t get me wrong: I’m happy for every person who decides that they don’t want to opt into the sex culture (and I think they have a biblical basis). However, there should be space inside the church for those who want to have sex and those who do not, regardless of sexual orientation. This framing of celibacy as a punishment, intentional or not, has put sex on a pedestal and dismissed those who do not partake.

Choosing not to have sex is not a punishment, nor is it an infantile decision, and the church should respect (and celebrate!) people who go down that route without forcing them down that route. Sex is not the end-all be-all. As we have racial, gender, cultural, and age diversity in church, there is room for sexual diversity too. 

Asexuality is often erased in the wider culture, and the same holds true for the church currently. Right now, being asexual in the church feels like being the model minority of the LGBTQ+ community—you fit in just enough to not stick out as long as you don’t make any waves. But if the church is to be truly inclusive of all queer people, we’ve got to rethink how we treat celibacy.

4 Comments

  1. Geneva Langeland

    Ace solidarity! I’m ace and bi, which (for me) means that I can find people of any gender identity cute, but my body’s response to their cuteness is generally a big shrug. Here’s to greater ace visibility and acceptance!

    Reply
    • Alex Johnson

      Heck yeah. Happy Pride Month to you ❣️

      Reply
  2. Lauren

    Thank you so much for writing this!

    I was thinking along similar lines today: why is it that the church is so insistent on forcing asexuality on people who are not asexual (such as priests, lesbians, gays, unmarried people) but completely ignores naturally asexual people? As you said, it just makes me feel super weird as an asexual person, that the church barely mentions asexuality or acknowledges its existence but then essentially forces it down everyone’s throats. I fly under the radar and my asexuality mostly goes unnoticed and undiscussed but then my lesbian friend tries to remain closeted but still receives the unsolicited advice of her “Christian” parents and peers that she needs to act like she’s asexual for her whole life — like what?! Make it make sense!

    Additionally, asexuality is only celebrated when you’re imposing it on yourself due to religious reasons, not when it’s naturally who you are. (When it’s naturally who you are, people either don’t care or they think it’s not real and you’re making it up.) If this was actually about what the Bible said (i.e. 1 Corinthians 7:8-9), it seems to me that naturally asexual people would be celebrated at least as much as homosexual people are condemned. But we aren’t. So this is really just about heteronormativity, right? Straight people having all the power in Christian communities, making all LGBTQ+ people feel unwelcome at church, regardless if their particular type of LGBTQ + is “sinful” according to the Bible or not. 🙁

    Reply
    • Alex Johnson

      Yes yes yes. “Asexuality is only celebrated when you’re imposing it on yourself due to religious reasons, not when it’s naturally who you are.” I have had the classic “oh I guess you are still figuring things out” comment when talked about a sexuality, but you’re right if I was wearing a purity ring or something, I would be commended for my strength. It all comes down the power, you’re absolutely right.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related posts

Lacking a Love Language
by Lauren Cole, February 11, 2021
Mine Is the Easy Job
by Lillie Spackman, June 19, 2022
Moses and Me
by Alex Johnson, June 5, 2021
Yuhki and Me
by Annaka Koster, June 26, 2021
Gays for SAO
by Gwyneth Findlay, April 9, 2019

post calvin direct

Get new posts from Alex Johnson delivered straight to your inbox.

the post calvin