In the 1946 Christmas classic It’s a Wonderful Life, influential plebeian George Bailey is granted a wish to see what life would’ve been like without his existence. But when the disbelieving George walks back into town to see his wife, kids, and business partners, it is not the amicable Bedford Falls community he is returning to, but the cold, poverty-stricken slums of “Pottersville,” named after the wicked old miser who ran everyone else out of business. The friendly, low-income neighborhood of Bailey Park has become a graveyard, Martini’s lively tavern has changed hands to a surly bartender named Nick, and George’s beautiful old house has become an abandoned haunt again. It seems that George’s influence everywhere has been replaced by Potter’s; history has taken a turn for the worse.

If bad luck accompanies name associations, Potterville, Michigan sure makes a case for the superstition. It was founded in 1846 by the hardnosed Linus Potter, the first supervisor for Benton Township. A dogged settler if ever there was one, Linus traveled by steamboat to Detroit and proceeded to walk sixty miles inland, carrying his three-year-old son and infant daughter the whole way, before deciding on a suitable place to start life in Michigan.

Since the early days, the city whose main claim to fame was “Gizzard Fest” has perfected an uncanny ability to invoke extraordinary calamities. Disasters that overcome wild odds, the kind that perpetuate the old adage, “truth is stranger than fiction.”

On a pleasant afternoon in July of 1994, a rogue lightning bolt shot down from a seemingly benign sky and hit the water at Fox Park, injuring twenty-two beachgoers. The sheriff’s report claimed that the bolt “walked up the beach,” a curious description for a phenomenon known for aquatic conductivity. But then again, lightning can be unpredictable…

Lightning also doesn’t strike the same place twice, according to myth, and so less than two months later Mother Nature decided to send Potterville an earthquake instead. You read that correctly—an earthquake. Most of mid-Michigan felt the tremor, but as the epicenter was just a couple miles east of town, Potterville weathered the brunt of it.

In 2002, the city let its guard down on Memorial Day only to experience one of the worst train derailments in US history. Thirty-five Canadian National railroad cars jumped the tracks at the Potterville Station for a calamitous wreck, and when it was discovered that each one of them was carrying a load of toxic propane, the entire city had to be evacuated.

It was starting to seem like a cruel twist of déjà voodoo when a second derailment occurred in 2006—same company, same location. But it wasn’t the fault of the tracks or the railroad station; blame was placed on a faulty wheel bearing in the eighty-second car, which means the only reason this occurred in Potterville and not Charlotte, or Lansing, or Toronto or Chicago…was dumb luck.

In August of 2008, a tornado touched down just south of town, wreaked F3-level havoc from the western city limit to the eastern city limit, and dissipated into the sky again.  It was the worst tornado to affect Southern Michigan since the Great Tornado Outbreak of 1991, which damaged many areas of the state, including—and you ought to be expecting this by now—Potterville.

On a cold night in January of 2010, a fire broke out in downtown Potterville, destroying historic main street edifices over a hundred years old. And it wasn’t just pet shops and apartments that burned. Like the twist of a knife after it enters the flesh, antique shops and bookstores were reduced to cinders as well. It took eight different fire departments to help battle the blaze, and just when they thought the fire was under control, Potterville’s water supply ran out, forcing the firemen to call for backup tankers. After twelve hours, the inferno was quelled, but Potterville Fire Department forgot about the “double tap rule.” Two days later, fire sprang up from the ashes, causing havoc and mayhem throughout the downtown business district before the firemen could put it down for good.

The list ends there, for now. As you can see though, the timeline suggests Potterville is overdue for another disaster. The Potterville Curse is alive and well. A creative (and slightly sadistic) mind wonders what’s next. Tornadoes and firestorms seem imminent, but if the trend for long-shot freak accidents continues, some unorthodox preparations might not be a bad idea. Perhaps the next train wreck will contain Stranger Things-like monsters from a top-secret governmental experiment, or the next lightning strike will come in the form of alien abductions. Maybe a sinkhole will emerge and swallow the town altogether. In any case, if there was ever a time for a real-life George Bailey to realize his worth, it is now.

In the meantime, be cautious about visiting Potterville. It’s worth a stop, certainly for a quirky lunch at Joe’s Gizzard City alone, but just remember that the time clock for calamity is ever ticking.

7 Comments

  1. Deb

    Well written!! You’ve summarized the Potterville curse very well! And it’s probably time for a new calamity…☹️

    Reply
  2. Jake Robertson

    Yes, well written. Been a lifelong resident you missed a few tragedies. Like the Kamp pallet fire in 2004that lasted seven days, another historic side of downtown burning in 2012 in the midst of an ice storm. Not to mention the fact that in it’s early days, 1870s two 1950s, The The downtown burned three full times taking out the historic Potter hotel that was a major stop on the train line. It’s because of those fires that Potterville was not the state capital which it was been eyed for when Michigan came to statehood
    Maybe for the sequel‍♂️
    Ps: we also had a villainous city manager for a few years

    Reply
  3. Nobody

    Aug of 2008 must have been the tornado that landed some mail in my yard from several miles away. I lived in Dimondale and a tornado came thru…next day I found mail from an address in Potterville.

    Reply
  4. Pope

    The Tornado Was Not In August Of 2008 It Was August 24 2007, I Know That Date Very Well It Hit The Day Before My Birthday and I Had Just Got Out Of The Hospital After Having Heart Surgery Our Neighborhood Looked Like A War Zone

    Reply
    • D.S Ryelle

      Concur. The 2008 tornado didn’t touch Potterville, it was off Strange Highway (in Grand Ledge addresses) and petered out in Grand Ledge proper.

      Reply
  5. Dan Reid

    One that you missed. The pallet factory fire on Lansing road. I’m not sure the date but I’m thinking 10-12 years ago. I live 10 miles west of town and went to help with what I thought was a local barn fire.
    The t.v. news weather report that night showed that the heat and water being used to put it out was creating its own weather system on radar. Pretty impressive.

    Reply
  6. Barb VanderMolen

    You neglected to mention all the infighting among various governing bodies. Embarrassing.
    On a brighter note, it was one of the original Potter children who donated the land for Potter Park Zoo.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

post calvin direct

Get new posts from Nick Meekhof delivered straight to your inbox.

the post calvin