I firmly believe that no city-trip is complete without at least one museum visit. On a cold autumn day last week, with the sky already dimming to dusk at 3p.m., my sister and I dragged ourselves across Berlin to visit the Stasi Museum and meet my minimum quota.

The museum is situated in the former headquarters of the Ministry for State Security, or the East German secret police force, colloquially known as the “Stasi.” Its public exhibitions occupy the offices of the Ministry’s former director, with large parts of the building left decorated and arranged just as they stood from 1961 to 1989.

Guided by an informational brochure, my visit began first with pictures documenting the extent of the Stasi and its agents, including the lead singer of a popular punk band and the personal assistant to West German Chancellor Willy Brandt.

Following signs, I then moved into the context-building next room. Its displays fell, understandably, into oversimplification and occasional cliché as they sought to teach visitors about the formation of East Germany, the role the Stasi played therein, and Marxist-Leninism, all within perhaps ten minutes of browsing.

After a brief commiseration with my sister on the room’s lack of nuance, from which I will spare my dear readers, we climbed the stairs to the next floor of the collection. Here, the museum takes a turn to much drier content. Instead of sweeping statements, one finds a room full of organigrams showing the bureaucratic structure of the Stasi, complete with detailed information on the personal history and specific roles of the people who led each department. Another room is dedicated to the acronyms used by the Ministry to describe their internal agenda, forty-something panels covering the walls to distinguish between IMEs, IMKs, IMSs, GMEs. A display case demonstrates the dual filing system that served as the Stasi’s central record on East German residents and the Ministry’s interest in them.

I found these rooms fascinating—but with their fluorescent lights, text-heavy panels, and extreme attention to detail, I also found them an odd choice for a museum. Did the curators really think that this format would most effectively drive the public’s engagement with its content? The displays read more like internal archives, or perhaps posters at a research conference.

A penultimate floor presents the Ministry Director’s offices as they were arranged during the active days of the Stasi, complete with a bust of Lenin in the hallway.

Finally, after one last flight of stairs, the tone of the exhibition shifts to conclude on a celebratory note. Looping videos and blown-up photographs show the night of January 15, 1990 when Berlin’s residents occupied the Ministry headquarters to prevent Stasi staff from destroying the records of their surveillance over the prior forty years.

Children, young people, the elderly—all generations walk up the stairs and through the hallways of the headquarters, looking into rooms and flipping through documents of the secret police. Following this dramatic initial occupation, Berliners then went on to organize themselves into a citizens’ committee that oversaw the movements of Ministry officials until German Reunification in 1991, preventing further destruction of records. Through their work, they safeguarded a hundred kilometers of intelligence files, one point seven million photographs, and 34,000 film and audio recordings from destruction1.

In this light, the meticulous panels composing the museum’s first floors take on a new dimension. Citizens did not merely prevent the destruction of records, but went on to analyze them, feeding into the museum’s collections now open to the public. One can imagine the countless people who poured over those thousands of files, bringing sense to endless acronyms and uncovering unknown breaches of privacy or betrayals of trust.

Paul Lynch, in his Irish dystopia Prophet Song, writes the following on authoritarian regimes and their control of information:

“I awoke and began to see what they were doing to us, the brilliance of the act, they take something from you and replace it with silence and you’re confronted by that silence every waking moment and cannot live, you cease to be yourself and become a thing before this silence, a thing waiting for the silence to end, a thing on your knees begging and whispering to it all night and day, a thing waiting for what was taken to be returned and only then can you resume your life, but the silence doesn’t end, you see, they leave open the possibility that what you want will be returned some day and so you remain reduced, paralyzed, dull as an old knife, and the silence does not end because the silence is the source of their power, that is its secret meaning.”

Lynch’s words on silence, here in reference to a character whose partner has been disappeared by the state, are equally relevant to the citizens of East Germany, surveilled for decades by an unfathomably dense secret police force and their informants. Many people became informants themselves, whether by incentive or blackmail, reporting on their neighbors and colleagues and friends. Some estimates hold that there may have been up to two million informants, in a country of sixteen million.

Can you imagine what that must have felt like? How paralyzing it must have been? To be so encompassed by this secret surveillance state, and then to walk freely through its halls?

The Stasi Museum is a direct response to the silence of the seemingly unknowably vast Ministry for State Security. The rooms of apparently extraneous detail are in fact the entire point of the museum. It is both archive-as-resistance and archive-as-memorial.

And so, if you ever find yourself in Berlin, and you too believe that a city trip is never complete without a museum visit, take the U-Bahn to Magdalenenstraße and visit the former headquarters of the Ministry for State Security. Disregard the signs guiding the direction of your visit and head directly to the last floor. Watch the faces of the protestors as they walk for the first time through the building where you now stand; watch both their euphoria and their trepidation. When you make your way downstairs and through the collection, and find yourself standing before a meticulous organization chart, remind yourself what this chart is: a shout into the silence.

—

1 Jamie Dettmer (2020), VOA News

Referenced: The Berliner (2024)

the post calvin