Standardized testing, the bane of every student’s existence. And I have joined the dark side.

The international school I teach at happens to be a SAT testing center, and I was recently asked to join the proctoring team. In our school’s classic casual fashion, I got the invitation in the form of a text message form our testing coordinator. And the text only needed this one sentence to get me on board: “You get paid!”

What has followed is a rather interesting series of conversations with both students and teachers about the infamous test.

From personal recountings of late night study sessions to parental laments over their child’s stresses, the SAT seems to provoke a reaction out of everyone directly and indirectly involved. Which makes sense. The two-and-a-half hour test supposedly holds a highschooler’s future within it’s confusing questions. Not only do colleges use these scores to determine admissions, but thousands of dollars of scholarships also ride on this one test. And, to a community of international students dreaming of studying in the English-speaking world, this test quickly becomes the wall standing between them and success.

As an international student on the other side of this academic tunnel, the light at the end of it now looks a little smaller than I once believed. That score did get me a good scholarship, but that felt like the end of it. None of it seemed “helpful” during my college career. Everyone in college, no matter their score, struggles with college learning. There’s no way around it. I felt like I was fortunate to like English enough to get a decent score. Others at Calvin seemed to share the same sentiments. Yes, it was a great way to get scholarships, but they felt like they got “lucky” or were just able to study hard enough to get decent scores. The real test of college-preparedness came in those first semester weeder classes.

What about those without access to such standardized testing? Are they out of the race simply due to circumstances? In many countries and communities, it sure feels that way. I almost didn’t take the SAT. When COVID hit, testing became practically impossible. I was able to take the last in-person test before they shut everything down. Colleges and universities made testing optional due to this sudden change in circumstances. But how different was it really? Even without COVID restrictions, there are millions of people across the world without access to the education and the testing “needed” to enter into the higher education atmosphere.

I’m just reiterating the common criticisms of standardized testing that many of us have heard since COVID. But what about the other side of this conversation?

Colleges across the US are going back to requiring SAT scores at admission due to a rather alarming trend. Students admitted during the test-optional period have displayed more and more struggle with the demands of college learning. And, with the literacy crisis making headlines, it makes sense to question whether the lack of required testing has loosened the pressure to teach and learn reading and writing to a higher academic degree. I’ve had multiple conversations with teachers and administrators who have all agreed that testing is a necessary evil. There really seems to be no other way to determine a student’s ability to handle the schooling ahead of them.

I sat outside our testing room as a hall monitor while five students took the SAT last week. Each of them wore their nerves on their faces. All of them left having left none of those nerves behind. I started writing this piece there, stirred by the look on those students’ faces. I can’t answer the question in the title of this piece. I empathize with the stress of my students, the ambivalence of college peers, and the frustration of fellow educators. At the end of the day, one 20-something year old LA teacher can only sit and offer some kind of comfort, encouragement, or conversation to make all of this confusion seem a little less lonesome.

the post calvin