As far as I know, nearly every high school in the country reads Shakespeare’s Romeo & Juliet, usually around the ninth grade. If you are reading this post, odds are that you at least pretended to read it at some point in your life.

I am often baffled as to how this play, of all the great Shakespeare plays, is the most commonly taught. Yet here I am, attempting to teach it to my ninth graders. While they may only have gleaned three new sexual euphemisms from it, I think I have actually learned several important things. So here is my new case of why, perhaps, Romeo & Juliet is still of value in the present day.

It explores the following important issues:

At its heart, the play is about the danger of divisions between people. Every three scenes or so, a bunch of dudes get into a fight in the streets because they are members of feuding households. (I will now give you three seconds to come up with two groups of people you may know who can barely be in the same room as each other without fighting.) In the play, this hatred escalates to the point in which two children take their own lives. I am not easily convinced that the two of them are truly in love, but I do believe that they are truly desperate and unable to seek help from their parents because of thoroughly-festered hatred.

Romeo has some serious obsession-with-women issues. Women have been glorified in his mind to such a degree that he is driven almost senseless with lust by two different women in the same day. His friends try to talk to him, and he instead spends several pages ranting about his current obsession. The night that he first meets Juliet, he sneaks around in her backyard to get a glimpse of her again. Somebody seriously needs to talk to the boy about healthy boundaries with women. Well, Friar Lawrence, bless his soul, tries to talk to Romeo about it, but he won’t listen. Romeo forces us to consider why someone would act in such an alarming manner towards a woman he just met.

Juliet is a young woman cracking under the unfair expectations placed on her. She is only thirteen, and she is lined up to be packaged off nicely in an arranged marriage. She constantly tries to play the dutiful daughter and later dutiful wife, but when Romeo arrives as an escape from these expectations, she nearly leaps out of her window to take the opportunity. Yet even in her rebellion, she has to jump through the hoop of a hasty marriage in order to justify her sexuality with Romeo. She seriously couldn’t handle the burden of female purity and perfection. While those standards may have changed, they are still stifling to many.

Toxic masculinity abounds, almost unchecked, throughout the play. There are all sorts of degrading jokes about women, clearly made between friends to earn manliness points. And two men are killed in a sword fight largely fought to assert their own dominance. If that doesn’t scream “check your obsession with masculinity before you are skewered by a sword,” I don’t know what does.

The greatest love story in this play is not Romeo and Juliet’s three-day relationship. It is their friends who will go to any lengths to help them. Romeo’s friends who will sneak into a party with him, risking their lives, in order to try to help him get over his crush. Juliet’s nurse, who raised her as her own, goes against her employer’s wishes in order to help her child she loves more than anything. Mercutio who dies in a sword fight to defend Romeo’s honor (*cough cough* manliness). Their friends don’t always make the wisest decisions, but they almost always do it out of love. Yet the saddest part is that in their obsession with each other, Romeo and Juliet are constantly oblivious to the people around them who love them so incredibly much.

Who knows if my students are getting the same thing out of this play. But at least I am finally beginning to see why there is value in Romeo & Juliet. Why they have remade it into a thousand movies, including one about gnomes and one about sea lions. It is a warning against the power of human hatred. It is an exploration about the expectations and emotions that overwhelm humanity. And it is a love story of people who tirelessly love and support their friends, even when they are being hopelessly impulsive teenagers.

Nice job, William, I guess you did it again.

5 Comments

  1. Avatar

    Excellent, says another English Major. I’m gonna send this to some teenagers I live with!

    Reply
  2. Avatar

    Susannah was my RA and I can confirm she is both talented & genius 🙂

    Reply
  3. Kyric Koning

    Too often we do overlook the love from those closest to us as mere “commonality” or “normality.” Thanks for the reminder to keep our eyes open and our hearts focused on others.

    Reply
  4. Avatar

    Love this. Maybe the teacher/professor gets more out of than the students? Wouldn’t be the only work for which this is true. If we think of R&J as, at least partly, Sh’s satire of our obsessions with romantic love, “the god of our idolatry,” the whole mess makes more sense.

    Reply
  5. Avatar

    To this day, I’m still surprised that I was required to read Comedy of Errors (which so many people I know haven’t even heard of) and never Romeo & Juliet. I guess I’m glad because my hopelessly romantic high school self would’ve swooned over it I’m sure. I appreciate your analysis, and the encouragement to find value in things that might make it difficult to do so.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

post calvin direct

Get new posts from Susannah Boersma delivered straight to your inbox.

the post calvin