My husband and I just started watching Gilmore Girls. It’s his first time, my tenth. It’s brought up a lot of questions: “how old were you when you watched this for the first time?” 16. “Did you ever have a ‘Dean’?” Hell no. “Which character are you? Which character am I?”

What is it about watching a movie or a TV show that makes us so strongly long to identify with a character, usually one towards the top of the call sheet? Buzzfeed made millions of dollars off this very idea. A few years ago, I started a fight amongst my friends after a rewatch of Mystic Pizza by trying to assign a character to each of us—believe it or not, everyone wanted to be Julia Roberts.

Sometimes it’s messier. For example, I am a Hannah Sun, Marnie Moon, Shossana Rising and my Venus is in Jessa, or I’m a Carrie with a Charlotte wing. I grew up a Jo and then turned into an Amy, mostly after watching Greta Gerwig’s interpretation of Little Women and having a deeper understanding of the youngest March sister.

When I moved to Chicago, I made my roommate watch Chicago-based movies and TV with me. Have you ever seen an episode of Chicago Fire? Take Grey’s Anatomy season 6 and multiply it by 10. We watched The Fugutive, While You Were Sleeping, Shameless, The Bear, The Dark Knight, etc. until my commute to work felt cinematic enough to stomach.

My husband and I just wrapped up Mad Men (his first time, my second). We delayed watching the last episode for about a week because my husband was, “worried about what’s going to happen to my friends.” Although I see my husband best represented in the character of Ginsberg, in truth he’s Peggy. And so am I.

I had an ex-boyfriend who—when we watched New Girl (his first time, my millionth)—couldn’t figure out which character he wanted to identify with. I knew going into it that I’m Winston, through and through. When—SPOILER ALERT—Winston finally meets his paramour, Ally, my ex finally claimed her, although I suspect there were ulterior motives in that choice.

Joan Didion once wrote, “We tell ourselves stories in order to live.” These stories we tell ourselves, through TV, books, movies, can become roadmaps in our lives. I knew I wasn’t actually Jo March, because if Laurie had confessed his love to me, I would’ve immediately thrown my values out the window to be with him. I know I’m not Carrie Bradshaw because me and my friends would have killed Mr. Big after season 1 and gone to jail for it. I know I’m not Peggy Olsen because that woman would have never left work early for a manicure.

Like Tom Hansen in 500 Days of Summer, I grew up believing I would never be truly happy until I met “the one.” This belief stems from early exposure to sad Taylor Swift music and a total misreading of the movie 13 Going On 30. I often look to these fictionalized worlds to create expectations for my life: “I need to date someone for x amount of years before getting engaged”, or “this certain age is too old to start over in a new career”, or “this exact city is where I need to live in order to be truly happy with my large apartment and even larger group of friends who are all free at the same time every day.”

This isn’t a novel way of moving through the world. I’m sure Jane Austen and the Brontë sisters received a lot of hate mail from poor, jilted young women who couldn’t understand why they and their four sisters hadn’t yet run into wealthy gentlemen who saw beyond their circumstances. In the past few years, I’ve learned to widen the breadth of stories I pay attention to, to seek out the ones that make the future seem more open and less formulaic. I just recommended a recently single friend watch the movie How To Be Single, with Dakota Johnson. Yes, it’s extremely on the nose, but it is also just another story to add to our repertoire when looking ahead.

Rewatching Gilmore Girls at twenty-six, married, and living in Tennessee of all places, it is harder to map the storylines onto my life. I’m not a teen mom or a brainy high school student. I don’t live in Connecticut, and I’m actually pretty good at communicating with my husband when we have a misunderstanding. So the next time my husband asks, “which character are you?” I have my answer. Obviously on first watch, I related to Rory, then more to Lorelei when Rory started acting out. Now I feel like the most honest answer to “who am I” is Babette, their crazy cat lady neighbor who loves to sit at home and listen to her husband play piano, mostly because I am a crazy cat lady and I love to sit at home and listen to my husband play guitar.

the post calvin